Last updated: June 8, 2025
| 2024 | Matthew Weddle |
| 2022 | Brady Marshall |
| 2019 | Timothy Owen Marshall |
| David Patrick Vreeland | |
| Michael Emmanuel Sullivan | |
| William Joseph Walto III | |
| 2018 | Thomas Garno |
| Joseph Wagner | |
| Matteo Baeyens | |
| 2017 | Jeremiah Ivar Sullivan |
| 2016 | Nicholas Haines |
| Sean Theoclitus | |
| Jonathan Soldan | |
| 2013 | Ian St. Clair |
| Kyle Hall | |
| 2012 | Patrick Sullivan |
| 2011 | Michael Rosato |
| Chris Chervenak | |
| Tom Puhak | |
| David Mascia | |
| 2010 | Drew Vautin |
| Eric Pesce | |
| Michael Lucente | |
| 2009 | Alexander Hrotko |
| Matthew Gerecht | |
| Paul Mascia | |
| 2008 | Mark Pesce |
| Nicholas Mozer | |
| Brian Waldele | |
| 2007 | Jonathan Morgan |
| 2006 | Guy Ercolano |
| 2005 | Patrick Amorosa |
| 2004 | Peter Varnai |
| 2003 | Thomas Ercolano |
| 2002 | Paul Grodziak |
| 1999 | Neil Thorn |
| Marc Russo | |
| 1997 | Joshua Kuhns |
| 1994 | Vincent Bochicchio |
| 1990 | Walter Schaeffler |
| 1987 | Bruce McIntyre |
| 1984 | Paul Soeffing |
| 1979 | Michael Kendzierski |
| 1963 | James Yankaskas |
| 1945 | Francis Cerulli |
| 1943 | Edward Grushinski |
| 1938 | Robert Denninger |